Việt Nam's New Environmental Fines Reach Carbon Trading Accounts and Smokestack Data Feeds

Most of Việt Nam’s environmental penalty decree reads the way you would expect: fines for dumping wastewater, for exceeding dust limits, for leaving rubbish in the wrong place. The new version, Nghị định 412/2026/NĐ-CP, still does all that. But two parts of it are about software and data rather than smoke and sludge. One governs the automatic monitoring systems that stream emissions readings to the authorities. The other sets out, for the first time, what it costs to break the rules of the domestic carbon trading system, up to and including exploiting a bug in the trading platform to take emission allowances or carbon credits.

The document

  • Number: 412/2026/NĐ-CP, issued by the Government on the proposal of the Minister of Agriculture and Environment.
  • Signed: 14 November 2026 by Deputy Prime Minister Hồ Quốc Dũng.
  • Effective: 14 November 2026, the day it was signed (Điều 86). The Government Office’s digital signature on the published copy is dated 18 November, so the decree had already been in force for four days when the text became public.
  • Replaces: Nghị định 45/2022/NĐ-CP of 7 July 2022, which ceased to have effect on the same day.
  • Size: 87 articles across 194 pages, plus annexes listing hazardous environmental parameters.

The legal bases include the Law on Environmental Protection 72/2020/QH14 (as amended, most recently by Luật 146/2025/QH15), the Law on Handling Administrative Violations, the Law on Biodiversity and, notably, the Law on Securities 54/2019/QH14. The last one is there because the carbon market runs on securities-market infrastructure.

The headline numbers have not moved

The ceiling is unchanged in practice: VND 1 billion per violation for individuals and VND 2 billion for organisations (Điều 6). As before, the amounts in the decree are written for individuals, and an organisation committing the same act pays double. The limitation period is two years (Điều 5). Additional sanctions still include suspending environmental permits and suspending operations for 1 to 24 months.

The old decree only pointed to the Law on Handling Administrative Violations for the maximum. The new one writes the figures into Điều 6.

Monitoring data: the fines for going dark rise

Large dischargers must run automatic, continuous monitoring systems for wastewater, dust and industrial exhaust, and send the readings straight to the provincial Department of Agriculture and Environment. Điều 16 sets the fines (individual rates; double for companies):

Behaviour Nghị định 45/2022 Nghị định 412/2026
Installing the system late 50–60 million 50–60 million
Non-compliant equipment, improper operation, not keeping the data 80–100 million 80–100 million
Not connecting or not transmitting data to the authority 80–100 million 100–150 million
No monitoring camera or no automatic sampler 80–100 million 100–150 million
Not protecting data confidentiality and integrity; tampering with readings before transmission 100–150 million 100–150 million
No monitoring system at all 150–200 million 150–200 million

So a company whose data feed goes quiet now faces VND 200–300 million, the same band as a company caught altering readings. The new text also spells out what “proper operation” means: setting the measuring range, quality assurance, periodic testing, manual monitoring while the system is down, and quality control before commissioning and every year after.

Điều 8 matters as much as the fines. Readings from a company’s own automatic monitoring system can be used as evidence against that company, provided the system has been tested, inspected and calibrated and is one that must transmit data directly to the provincial department. Results from registered monitoring-service providers and designated inspection bodies count too. Penalty procedures can be handled electronically under Nghị định 118/2021/NĐ-CP as amended by Nghị định 190/2025/NĐ-CP. Each monitoring system is counted as a separate violation (Điều 7).

The rules on environmental databases (Điều 44) carry over the 2022 levels. Illegally accessing a system that stores environmental data costs VND 10–40 million, and altering or deleting environmental data or monitoring results costs VND 60–80 million. Giving the authorities false monitoring data, or reporting figures that don’t match actual pollution, is VND 100–150 million.

The carbon market gets its own penalty chapter

Nghị định 45/2022 had one article on greenhouse gases, about inventory reports. The new decree has eight (Điều 46–53). They cover every player in the domestic carbon trading system: the companies that must report emissions, carbon trading members, depository members, the settlement bank, the Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi stock exchanges, the Vietnam Securities Depository and Clearing Corporation, and the businesses that trade.

Emitters (Điều 46). Late emissions reports are now graded. Under 31 days late draws a warning. From 31 to under 91 days costs VND 50–80 million. Beyond 91 days, or not filing at all, costs VND 80–100 million. Misstating total emissions by 10% or more costs VND 30–50 million. Emitting more than the allocated quota is fined on a scale based on the excess:

  • under 1,000 tonnes CO₂e: a warning for a first offence, VND 10–20 million if repeated;
  • 1,000 to under 3,000 tonnes: VND 20–75 million;
  • 3,000 to under 5,000 tonnes: VND 100–300 million;
  • 5,000 tonnes or more: VND 300–400 million.

The offender must also hand over any illegal gain.

Trading and depository members (Điều 47–48). Brokers must keep carbon trading strictly separate from securities trading. The customer’s account has to display the carbon and securities components separately from the moment of login. Allowances and credits must be accounted for separately, and cross-netting or lending them against other trading is banned. Breaches cost VND 50–75 million, and so does failing to keep customer accounts and records confidential. A false or misleading application to join the trading system costs VND 100–150 million plus a 1–3 month suspension.

Traders (Điều 53). Placing a buy order without the cash, or a sell order without the allowances, costs VND 20–30 million, as does trading allowances outside the official system. Two acts sit at the top of the scale, VND 600 million to 1 billion:

  • colluding, spreading false rumours or giving misleading information to manipulate allowance or credit prices, where it falls short of a crime. This also brings a 3–6 month trading suspension and repayment of the illegal gain;
  • “taking advantage of incidents or vulnerabilities in the information technology system” to take allowances or carbon credits, again short of a crime. The tools and assets used are confiscated.

For an organisation, both double to VND 1.2–2 billion. Under Điều 81, these cases can be published by name, along with any suspended trading or depository member, on government portals or the national database of administrative violations.

Who is affected

  • Factories and industrial zones with automatic monitoring obligations. A data feed that goes down is now an expensive problem, and the system’s own records can be used against you.
  • Companies on the greenhouse-gas inventory list, which now face firm deadlines and a fine based on how far they exceed their quota.
  • Securities companies acting as carbon trading or depository members. They need to check that their apps and back offices meet the separation and confidentiality rules.
  • Monitoring-equipment vendors and integrators. Data integrity, cameras and transmission are now the client’s legal exposure, and so a selling point.

Open questions

  • Organisation rates for quota overruns. Điều 46(6) describes exceeding the quota as an organisation’s violation, but the general rule in Điều 6 doubles every listed amount for organisations. Whether the top band is VND 400 million or 800 million will depend on how inspectors read it.
  • Deterrence. Even doubled, a maximum of VND 800 million for any excess of 5,000 tonnes or more could be cheaper than buying allowances when the overrun is large. The decree adds disgorgement of illegal gains, but how that gain is calculated is not spelled out.
  • Retroactivity. The decree applied from 14 November but was published on 18 November. Under the transition rule (Điều 85), violations that ended before 14 November are judged under the decree in force when they ended. Ongoing violations fall under the new one.
  • “Vulnerability” versus crime. The line between an administrative fine for exploiting a platform flaw and a criminal case for appropriating property is not defined. Expect it to be settled case by case.

Sources

This post is general information, not legal advice.